With the 55th Pacific Islands Forum Leaders Meeting (PIFLM) approaching, Natuman said Pacific leaders have an opportunity to reconsider the issue and determine how the region can respond to continuing concerns about human rights and the wellbeing of the people of West Papua.
Natuman, a former Prime Minister, said the Forum had previously proposed sending a delegation to West Papua to assess the human rights situation directly. However, he said the Forum had written to the Indonesian Government regarding the proposed visit but had not received a response.
He said direct access remains important if Pacific leaders are to develop a clearer understanding of the situation and consider reports of human rights concerns raised at regional and international levels.
The proposed visit could provide a fact-finding mechanism for Pacific countries, allowing representatives to engage with relevant stakeholders and assess conditions before reporting their findings to the Forum.
Natuman said the issue also extends to the participation of West Papuan representatives in regional and international forums, where he claimed their involvement has faced obstacles.
He pointed to similar challenges within the Melanesian Spearhead Group and said there would be no West Papuan delegation attending the upcoming PIF.
Natuman also referred to discussions surrounding West Papua at United Nations human rights mechanisms in Geneva, arguing that Indonesia’s position within international institutions has presented additional challenges for those seeking greater access to the territory.
With the Forum meeting approaching, Natuman said Pacific leaders should reconsider the issue and determine whether a clear regional position can be reached on allowing an independent delegation to visit West Papua.
For Vanuatu, he said the matter remains connected to the wider Pacific concern for human rights, dignity and the wellbeing of Melanesian peoples.
The proposed delegation represents one possible avenue for the Pacific Islands Forum to engage with the West Papua issue through regional dialogue, fact-finding and human rights assessment while maintaining diplomatic engagement with Indonesia.
The outcome of discussions in Palau could influence how the Forum approaches West Papua in future and whether the region can advance efforts for independent access to assess reported human rights concerns.
I want to tell you about a place I've come to understand as one of the most profound institutions on Earth. It's known by many names across Melanesia—Mbelamu to the Walak people, Pilamo to the Hubula, Nakamal in Vanuatu, Haus Tambaran along the Sepik River. Western observers, looking through their own cultural lenses, called it the "Men's House." But that translation misses almost everything that matters.
As Elder Wewo Kotokay explains it, this place is more accurately understood as a Living Sacred Site—a space where humans remember that we are naturekind, not separate from nature but woven into its fabric, interdependent with every other community of beings: families, clans, spirits, plants, animals, elements, and seasons.
What can this ancient institution teach us in our modern world of disconnection and environmental crisis? Quite a lot, it turns out.
One of the most beautiful names for this sacred space is the "Fire House." And it's not metaphorical in the way we might assume.
Inside the Story House, the fire burns continuously—day and night, through all seasons. Not a roaring blaze, usually, but a quiet, persistent flame that never dies. Why? Because the fire represents life itself. If neglected, it fades. If cared for, it sustains the community.
The practical significance is beautiful: while storytellers speak and listeners learn, hands stay busy tending the fire. It's a form of active listening that keeps the heart of the community alive. The fire provides warmth in the cold highlands, light in the dim interior, and a place to cook the "first harvest"—always offered first to the elders in the Fire House.
Beyond the physical flame, the Fire House represents a profound truth: the things that sustain us require daily attention. Culture, relationships, language, education, justice, the wellbeing of future generations—these are our modern "fires." They cannot be maintained through occasional attention; they require daily care, commitment, and responsibility.
Perhaps the most revealing name is the "Story House." Because the primary activity within its walls is storytelling—not as entertainment, but as the living repository of knowledge, law, ethics, spirituality, history, ecology, and identity.
The Koteka tribes distinguish between two types of stories: Wene mbililik (storylines) and Wene mbalek (customary laws). The storylines present a comprehensive picture of life—of spirits, plants, animals, elements, and humans. And from these storylines, customary laws are formulated.
Here's what makes this so powerful for conservation:
First, the stories comprehensively map "spirit hotspots"—important places, persons, and elements of the earth. The entire biosphere of an area is mapped within the storylines.
Second, the stories always relate to local vicinities. They don't speak about something beyond or above—they talk about what speakers and listeners can name, point to, and visualize. Mountains, rivers, trees, animals, clan names. The stories are made alive and practical in daily life.
Third, the customary laws enforce limitations and obligations for humans, helping them function as caretakers of these hotspots for the sake of resilience and sustainability.
The stories are transmitted through three primary methods: crying songs (lamentation) that welcome guests into the house, actual storytelling, and the mbokngayok (mouth harp) whose music carries messages. Storytellers are the most creative speakers—they can be the ones solving problems and resolving conflicts.
And here's a profound detail: elders say that while there are so many stories told with different names and variations, in actual fact, there is only one story and one storyline across Melanesia.
The concept of the "Spirit House" is perhaps the most accurate descriptor. Melanesian peoples, especially the Koteka tribes, believe, speak, and tell stories without making any distinction at all between spirit and material worlds, between human beings and other-than-humans.
The Spirit House is not merely a building where men gather, but a sacred space where the spirit of all communities of beings—living and dead, human and more-than-human—is illuminated, organized, strengthened, and nurtured. It serves as a portal between worlds.
Kotokay describes it as an "altar where all beings alter from one to the other beings." This captures the transformative, relational character of the space. It actively creates conditions for interaction between different orders of being.
In the Spirit House, human beings come to realize that we exist because of others—that nothing exists on its own. It's the place where other human beings and other-than-humans are provided space to inter-act and further "inter-seep."
The Spirit House is also where the merging between the dream world and awake world occurs. People inside will be telling stories, sometimes continuing after they've physically fallen asleep. Listeners may be sleeping, even snoring, while stories continue—deliberately allowed so the stories can reach both awake and dream realities.
The Spirit House accepts and sends signals beyond the physical realm. It represents the cosmos, with what you might think of as both a remote control and a projected screen to monitor and remotely interact.
The Earth House and Spirit House: Two Sides of Wholeness
One final distinction is crucial. The Spirit/Fire House is complemented by what Kotokay calls the "Earth House"—the domain of women, associated with Water rather than Fire.
Both are Story Houses, but they tell different stories. The Earth House's topics surround foods, drinks, gardening, cooking, eating, and the spirit of the society. There's a clear horizontal orientation.
The Spirit House is more directed toward something vertical—the overall web of life, inter-relationships, inter-connections, inter-dependence. Far beyond human affairs, toward nature affairs.
I won't say more about the Earth House here—as Kotokay explains, he is a male elder, and for him to define the Earth House would be a violation of fundamental ethics. The two complement each other, and each must speak from its own place.
The Spirit House operates according to specific protocols that serve a common purpose: balance for harmony. Here are some of the most striking:
• The "Water-Fire" seating arrangement: The interior is organized around a central hearth with four pillars, corresponding to the cardinal directions. Members of the Wita (Fire) and Waya (Water) clans face each other, creating a visual representation of cosmic balance.
• Controlled illumination: The house is kept dim—bright light is considered discourteous to the collective of human and spirit presences.
• Auditory and kinetic restraint: Conversations are conducted in subdued tones, movements with deliberate slowness. A marked auditory calm prevails.
• No negative speech: Criticism, cursing, shouting, complaints, and gossip are strictly prohibited.
• Deep listening: Listeners practice an intense, embodied form of listening. They may adopt a recumbent posture, integrating the story into a state of heightened, contemplative receptivity.
• Repetition as pedagogy: Stories are told repeatedly—not for entertainment, but to inscribe the narratives into memory and being until the listener is transformed into a story holder and storyteller.
• Fragmentary transmission: The complete corpus of a given narrative may never be fully disclosed. Understanding may require lifelong pursuit and significant investment.
It's worth being clear about what this sacred institution is not:
• It's not a place for spirits to demonstrate power—it's built for human beings, who host the spirit and invite other-than-human beings to participate in deliberations.
• It's not a ritual site to call spirits—there are no particular rituals to summon spirits. The only thing humans do is create an atmosphere conducive for all beings to convene, commune, and interact.
• It's not a magic site for miracles—it's an ordinary house for ordinary, everyday life.
• It's not a place for spirit worship—it's for human beings to interact and interweave with other-than-humans.
For Melanesians, everywhere is sacred, every time is special time. The goal is always to live in relation and respect with others.
The Spirit House is not a museum piece. It's not a fossil of a vanishing world. It's a living institution that has adapted across millennia and continues to adapt. From physical structure to digital platform. From local gathering to global network. From oral tradition to multimedia archive.
The form changes; the fire remains.
As Elder Jhon Kwano of West Papua speaks of 4+1 Worlds—with World Five arriving soon—one proof of that arrival is the incorporation of the Story/Spirit House into modern organizations working for resilience and sustainability on this planet.
The Spirit House is a governing body—a complex system of governance developed over thousands of years that organizes the balance of inter-relationships among communities of beings. It's a Melanesian school of thought, what we might call a university, where philosophy, politics, law, ethics, skills, theology, and art are taught.
In this school, knowledge is not limited to anthropocentrism and materialism. It addresses the rights of all communities of beings to live according to their roles and functions that contribute to life on this planet.
The fire does not ask whether you are Melanesian. It does not ask whether you are Indigenous. It does not ask whether you live in a village or a city, on an island or a continent.
It asks only one thing: Will you tend it?
The fire is burning. It is our responsibility to tend it.
To tend the fire means to take responsibility for what matters most. To ensure that the stories, values, relationships, and ecological wisdom that sustain life are not allowed to fade. To gather. To listen. To share. To care—for each other, for the land, for the beings with whom we share existence, and for the generations yet to come.
In a world of increasing disconnection, the Melanesian Living Sacred Site offers us something precious: a model of community, a practice of relationship, and a way of understanding our place in the web of life.
The fire is burning. The stories are waiting. The spirits are present.
Will you tend the fire?
This article is based on the teachings of Elder Wewo Kotokay, founder of Melanesian Conservation Elders, Inc., and his work on the Melanesian Spirit House as a living institution for community, story, and the sacred.
The original chapter (Chapter 2 of a forthcoming book) draws on the spiritual, natural, and cultural wisdom of the Koteka tribes of New Guinea Island, including the Lani, Walak, Yali, Hubula, Huli, Hela, Damal, Amungme, Nduga, Nggem, Gimi, Kafe, and others.